Category: Contested Divorce
What to Expect in a Contested Divorce Hearing in Ontario Courts
Pre-Hearing Steps in a Contested Divorce
Before a contested divorce hearing takes place in Ontario, there are several important procedural steps designed to prepare the case and encourage settlement where possible.
- Filing Applications, Responses, and Supporting Documents
The process begins when one spouse (the applicant) files an Application for Divorce with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. In contested matters, the application will include claims for relief—such as property division, custody, or support—along with supporting evidence. The other spouse (the respondent) must file a Response within the prescribed time frame, setting out their position and any counterclaims.
Ontario Divorce Lawyer Role in a Contested Divorce Case
Understanding a Contested Divorce in Ontario
A contested divorce in Ontario occurs when spouses cannot reach an agreement on one or more key issues related to the breakdown of their marriage. Under Canada’s Divorce Act, a divorce can only be granted if the marriage has broken down, typically proven by living separately for at least one year, or through cases involving adultery or cruelty. However, when there are disagreements over matters such as property division, child custody and parenting time, or spousal support, the divorce becomes contested.
Contested divorces often involve:
What Is a Contested Divorce in Ontario? Understanding the Legal Process
Definition and Key Features
A contested divorce in Ontario occurs when spouses cannot reach an agreement on one or more critical aspects of their separation. Unlike an uncontested divorce—where both parties agree on all terms—a contested divorce requires legal intervention, often involving lengthy court proceedings.
In Toronto and across Ontario, a divorce is considered contested if even a single issue is in dispute. These issues may involve:
- Child Custody and Access: Determining where the children will live and how parenting time will be shared.
- Child Support: Disagreements over the amount, duration, or responsibility for child support payments.
Common Reasons for Contested Divorces in Ontario
Child Custody and Parenting Disputes
Disagreements Over Decision-Making Authority
In Ontario, decision-making responsibility (formerly referred to as “custody”) determines who can make important choices regarding the child’s education, health care, religion, and general welfare. One parent may seek sole decision-making rights, while the other insists on joint authority. These disputes often arise when communication has broken down or trust has eroded.
Conflicting Parenting Schedules
Another common point of contention is the parenting time schedule (previously “access”). One parent may want more time than the other is willing to offer, or disagree on how weekends, holidays, and vacations should be divided. These disputes are often fuelled by concerns about logistics, lifestyle differences, or a desire for control.
How Long Does a Contested Divorce Take in Ontario?
Filing the Divorce Application
The process begins when one spouse files a divorce application with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice.
- Initiating the Divorce: The applicant completes and files a Form 8 (General Application) along with other necessary documents.
- Serving the Documents: The other spouse (the respondent) must be formally served with the divorce papers, often by a process server.
- Response Deadline: The respondent has 30 days (or 60 days if served outside Canada or the U.S.) to file a response.
This stage typically takes 2 to 4 weeks, depending on how quickly service is completed and whether the respondent meets the deadline.
How to Reduce Conflict in a Contested Divorce: Practical Tips for a Smoother Process
Understanding Contested Divorce in Ontario
A contested divorce occurs when spouses cannot reach an agreement on key issues related to their separation, requiring court intervention to resolve disputes. This differs from an uncontested divorce, where both parties mutually agree on all aspects, including child custody, spousal support, and asset division.
In Ontario, contested divorces often arise due to disagreements over:
- Child custody and parenting time – Disputes regarding decision-making responsibilities and access schedules.
- Spousal and child support – Conflicts over the amount and duration of financial support.
- Division of property – Disputes over how assets and debts should be divided, including the matrimonial home.
How to Prepare for a Contested Divorce Trial: Documents, Evidence, and Witnesses
Understanding Contested Divorce in Ontario
What is a Contested Divorce?
A contested divorce is one in which both spouses do not agree on key terms of their separation, such as:
- Child custody and parenting arrangements
- Division of assets and debts
- Spousal support and child support
Unlike an uncontested divorce, where both parties agree to the terms and simply need a judge’s approval, a contested divorce can be a lengthy and complex legal process. These cases often require multiple court appearances, evidence submissions, and witness testimonies before a judge makes a final ruling.
Legal Grounds for a Contested Divorce in Ontario – What You Need to Know
Understanding the Legal Grounds for Divorce in Canada
Canada operates under a No-Fault Divorce System, which means that spouses do not need to prove wrongdoing or misconduct to obtain a divorce. However, the Divorce Act provides three legal grounds under which a couple can seek a divorce:
- Separation for at Least One Year
-
- This is the most commonly used ground for divorce in Canada.
- Spouses must have lived separately for at least 12 consecutive months before a divorce is granted.
How a Judge Decides a Contested Divorce in Ontario – Key Factors
The Role of a Judge in a Contested Divorce
When and Why a Judge Steps In
A judge steps in when parties fail to reach an agreement despite efforts through alternative dispute resolution methods. In Ontario, the courts encourage couples to settle their differences outside the courtroom through mediation or arbitration. However, if an impasse remains, the judge assumes the role of an impartial decision-maker to resolve the contested issues in compliance with Ontario’s Divorce Act and Family Law Act.
The Judge’s Role in Ensuring a Fair and Legal Resolution
Appealing a Contested Divorce Ruling in Ontario: When & How to Challenge
When You Can Appeal a Contested Divorce Ruling
Not every unfavourable divorce ruling can be appealed. Ontario courts follow strict guidelines on what constitutes valid grounds for an appeal. If you plan to challenge a judge’s decision, it’s essential to understand when an appeal is legally justified.
Grounds for Appeal
A contested divorce ruling may be appealed if there are legal errors in the judge’s decision. The key grounds for appeal include:
- Legal Errors in the Judge’s Decision
-
- If the judge misapplied the law or failed to consider key legal principles, the ruling may be overturned.